Washington State Supreme Court narrows probable-cause grounds in pot case.

 

Law-enforcement officers who smell marijuana coming from a vehicle can’t arrest all of the occupants, the state Supreme Court ruled Thursday.

 

By Leslie Anne Jones Seattle Times

 

Law-enforcement officers who detect the odor of marijuana from a vehicle can’t arrest all of the occupants, the state Supreme Court ruled Thursday. 

In a unanimous ruling, the court determined the smell of pot isn’t enough probable cause to warrant the arrest and search of everyone inside a car. While smell alone may be reason for a vehicle search, the court determined, it doesn’t warrant handcuffing passengers without other supporting evidence. 

Defense attorneys on Thursday called it a right-to-privacy victory. Law-enforcement officers say it won’t greatly affect the way they make arrests. 

The ruling stems from a traffic stop in April 2006 in Skagit County. 

Jeremy Grande was riding in a car driven by Lacee Hurley when they were pulled over by State Patrol Trooper Brent Hanger, court documents said. Hanger stopped the car for windows too darkly tinted, he testified. 

Hanger said he smelled pot in the car, so he arrested and handcuffed Grande and Hurley, court documents said. 

A search of Grande revealed a glass pipe with marijuana in his pocket, according to court papers. Hanger searched the car and found a joint in an ashtray, which Hurley said belonged to her, court documents said. Both were charged with marijuana possession. Grande was also charged with possession of drug paraphernalia, court documents said. 

The case initially came before the Skagit County District Court, which found there was no probable cause for Grande’s arrest. But the state appealed the ruling and the county’s Superior Court reversed the order, court documents said. The case was appealed to the state Supreme Court. 

Summing up the state Supreme Court’s decision, Justice Charles W. Johnson wrote: “Our state constitution protects our individual privacy, meaning that we are free from unnecessary police intrusion into our private affairs unless a police officer can clearly associate the crime with the individual.” In the case of the Skagit County traffic stop, the court found the mere presence of the odor of marijuana was not enough probable cause to warrant the arrest of Grande. 

Attorney David Zuckerman, who brought the case before the state Supreme Court, said the problem is that arresting someone based solely on the odor of marijuana can affect innocents. 

“The smell of marijuana smoke can linger for weeks,” Zuckerman said. “You could have a perfectly innocent citizen get into a car where somebody smoked marijuana at some point … and an officer can just pull you out of a car and book you based on that.” 

Zuckerman said Grande was delighted with the decision. 

The decision doesn’t mean an officer must walk away from a vehicle that smells of pot. Trooper Hanger did have probable cause to search the car, the state Supreme Court decision said, just not to arrest Grande. 

“What this means is officers are going to have to be a little more keen in their investigative skills,” said Don Pierce, executive director of the Washington Association of Sheriffs and Police Chiefs. 

“Normally, if you come across the odor of marijuana … there’s something else going on that helps you identify who the responsible person or persons is.” 

Thursday’s decision overturned a 1979 state Court of Appeals decision that the smell of marijuana in a car established cause to arrest passengers and driver. But that decision was made three weeks before the U.S. Supreme Court held that the search of a person must be supported by probable cause that’s specific to that person. 

 

Somatostatin
Generic cialis
Phentermine buy order
Paramethadione
How does phentermine work
Phentermine online
Soma addiction
No online prescription xanax
Lopressor
Zafirlukast
Valtrex
1 loss phentermine pill weight
Cialis levivia viagra compare
Phentermine uk suppliers
Levofloxacin
Viagra compared to levivia
Lescol
Cozaar
Phentermine free shipping
Ambien
Pfizer viagra online
Famvir
Viagra
Lopid
Phentermine withdrawal
Does viagra work
No prescripton phentermine
Amoxicillin
Phentermine testimonials
Natural supplement for viagra
Phentermine rx
Xanax liver damage
What does phentermine look like
Xanax alcohol
Cheap phentermine online 37 5
Donepezil
Phentermine without prescription and energy pill
Natural alternatives to viagra
Taking phentermine
Demerol
Canada cialis
Online phentermine
Buy viagra uk
Xanax withdrawal
Nialamide
Fioricet
Phentermine no prescription required
Purchase soma
Herbal viagra uk
Phentermine information
Cephapirin
Viagra substitutes
Linkdomain buy online viagra info domain buy onlin
Thiopropazate
Buy cod pay phentermine
Soma financial
Senna
Methotrexate
Viagra tablets
Phentermine interactions
Canada cheap viagra
Any drug interaction xanax and cold meds
Ephedrine
Viagra wholesale
Low dose of viagra
Buy tramadol
Diet online phentermine pill purchase
Tramadol pharmacy
Tramadol addiction
Herbal viagra alternative review
Ativan
Enebrel
Cheapest phentermine 90 day orders
Viagra substitute
Mixing viagra and cialis
Prescription for viagra
Time released phentermine
Cialis viagra
Flagyl
Butalbital
Famciclovir
Discount fioricet
Fluoxetine
Phentermine 37 5mg
Xanax drug tests
Phentermine free online consultation
Cialis day next
Lotrimin
Viagra testimony
Phenytoin
Natural alternative viagra
Online xanax prescription
Viagra free consultation
Free generic viagra samples
Generic vicodin
Atropine
Viagra dose
Fluorouracil
Alfentanil
Thiamine
Generic soma
Effects long side term xanax
Viagra pharmacy
Iodipamide
Buy link onlinezwapto viagra
Cheap tramadol prescriptions online
Phentermine addiction
Generic viagra cialis
Non prescription xanax
Atrovent
Prescription soma
Phentermine 37.5 mg no prescription
Cialis drug prescription
Cheapest viagra prices
Valsartan
Cheapest price phentermine online pharmacy
Zanaflex
Permax
Ambien on line
Lowest price for phentermine
Akane soma
Cheap phentermine no prescription
Inderal
Delivered phentermine
Vicodin hp
Ssri phentermine heart
Killer pain tramadol
Prescription free viagra
Phentermine usa
Cheapest diet phentermine pill
Lowest cost phentermine guarantee free shipping
Effects of long term xanax use
Cod tramadol
Methyldopa
Phentermine without perscription
Natural phentermine
Picture of xanax
Betaxolol
Carteolol
Compare levivia and viagra
Phentermine sales online
Dont buy on black market get viagra legally
Ethinyl
Tramadol abuse
Buy cheap cialis
Cheap xanax
Free shipping cheap phentermine
Simethicone
Fluticasone
Viagra 6 free samples
Death cases from taking phentermine
Levitra vs cialis
Phentermine blue
Phentermine blogging
Purchase tramadol
Lotrel
Buy xanax without a prescription
Viagra alternative and woman
Mometasone
Viagra levivia
Buy cheap domain online outdoors com xanax
Cialis prescriptions
Generic viagra from india
Prednisolone
Phentermine online no prescription
Ritodrine
Dobutamine
Hydrocodone mexican pharmacy what is tramadol
Prescriptions on line phentermine
Misoprostol
Fioricet addiction
Shipping phentermine to florida
Cardizem
Xanax 2mg generic alprazolam 180 pills
Chlortetracycline
Medication drug mylan online search phentermine diet
Carphenazine
Zuclopenthixol
Order cialis uk
Alprazolam
Phentermine review
Relafen
Diltiazem
Nelfinavir
Liothyronine
Cheap phentermine cod
Discount viagra
Cialis levitra viagra vs vs
Phentermine buy best
Prinivil
What does xanax do
Acyclovir
Beconase
Phentermine 30 mg ordered with discover card
Buy online prescription viagra without
Cyclobenzaprine
Midazolam
Viagra sex
Phentermine 30 mg
Adderall skin allegra skin xanax skin
Generic xanax xr
Norfloxacin
Diet pill addiction phentermine
Tramadol drug interaction
Buy generic online phentermine
Zidovudine
Phentermine weight loss pills
Mestranol
Cash on delivery shipping of phentermine
Viagra samples free
Pediacare
Buying xanax online
Hexoprenaline
Compare cialis levitra
Phentermine online without prescription
Lindane
Phentermine purchase
Grapefruit xanax
Dexbrompheniramine
Cholestyramine
Aldara
Ampicillin
Tobramycin
Viagra cheap prescription
Laetrile
Menadione
Phentermine overnight shipping
Amiloride
Buy viagra
Chromium
Lamisil
Xanax abuse
Buy viagra order viagra
Phentermine ephedrine
Lovastatin
Phentermine adipex diet pill prescription
Pictures of xanax bars
Diet pill xanax
120 tramadol
Phentermine 37.5 in round white tablets no imprint code
Renova
Buy hydrocodone
Cialis forums
Viagra commercial
Natural viagra alternatives
Phentermine online cod
Viagra prices
Carbenicillin
Generic viagra reviews
Oxymorphone
Cheaper viagra levivia cyalis
On line prescription viagra
Alavert
Phentermine sales
Cialis and pomegranate interaction
Phentermine 37.5 free shipping
Cialis generic viagra
Picture of generic xanax
Terconazole
Iodoquinol
Chlorthalidone
Adipex
Xanax info
Buy phentermine in the uk
Generic price viagra
Phentermine lowest price 37.5 online
Buy generic xanax
Buy viagra 1
Buy soma online
Lethal dose xanax
Buying tramadol online
Diphenhydramine
Botox
Phentermine sale
Ritonavir
Does phentermine work
Hydrocodone overnight
Phentermine no rx
Bulk phentermine
Oxycodone vs hydrocodone
Discount drug phentermine
Symptom tramadol withdrawal
Method of payment accepted cod phentermine
Pilocarpine
Viagra from canada
Viagra info
Buy vicodin online
Sertraline
Finasteride
Generic viagra fast shipping
Berman sister female viagra study
$50.00 phentermine
Phentermine resin
Cheap tramadol 180
Viagra cialis comparison
Price viagra viacreme
Prescription phentermine with cod payment
Hydrocodone cough
Phentermine without doctor’s approval
Xanax overnight shipping

Comments are closed.